Insights

Who's Making the Investment Decisions? Why HORAN Wealth's New CIO Role Matters to Serious Investors

By: HORAN Wealth

When you've built real wealth—through a business, a career, or decades of disciplined saving—you start asking better questions.

Not, "What did the market do today?" 

Not, "What's the hot idea?"

The question that signals you're playing at a higher level is simple:

Who Is Actually Making the Investment Decisions—And How?

HORAN Wealth recently named David Templeton, CFA®, as Chief Investment Officer. And if you're an astute investor or a Private Wealth client, that move matters for one reason: it makes investment leadership explicit. It clarifies who owns the investment philosophy, the decision-making process, and the accountability that comes with managing complex portfolios through changing markets.

The Real Issue Isn't a Lack of Information—It's Too Much of It

David has been writing and educating clients for decades because he's watched the same pattern repeat: people don't struggle because they can't find information. They struggle because they can't tell what matters.

As he puts it, "Now we're in this environment where it's just too much information out there." The challenge isn't getting data—it's "finding out what information is most useful." That's why, in David's view, "having a process where you can cut through all the smoke... that's what's important today."

That's also why an investment house needs more than good intentions. It needs a repeatable investment process—one that's designed to reduce noise, not amplify it.

What HORAN's Investment Philosophy Actually Looks Like

In plain terms, David describes the philosophy as "high-quality investments that you can purchase at a reasonable price"—what he calls "growth at a reasonable price." That sounds simple, but it's the kind of simplicity that becomes powerful when markets get complicated.

It also explains why HORAN has been especially focused on concentration risk. David notes that "the index is less diversified today, so that's a risk." When a handful of names dominate market leadership, you can feel like you're diversified when you're not.

HORAN's approach is to "provide diversification while maintaining a focus on growth." That's disciplined investing in a sentence: pursue opportunity, but don't confuse a good year with a sound strategy.

The Hidden Value: Discipline That Removes Emotion from the Equation

Most investors don't get into trouble because they're unintelligent. They get into trouble because markets know exactly how to trigger emotion.

David says it plainly: "When it's your own money, you sometimes will make an emotional decision that might be incorrect." And he points to a moment most investors remember: "The COVID market pullback was a perfect example."

In that environment, what matters isn't predictions. It's behavior. Process. Perspective. A steady hand.

That's one of the clearest benefits of working with a disciplined outside investment team: "We're going to be less emotional." Not because emotion disappears—but because the decision-making structure is built to keep it from driving the car.

AI, Investing, and the Difference Between Signals and Decisions

David has an unusually grounded take on AI—interested, engaged, and not the slightest bit dazzled.

"We're using AI internally," he says. The practical value today? "Having AI help pull... the relevant pieces out of the whole web is beneficial." In other words: faster pattern recognition, better signal detection, less wasted time.

But he draws a hard line where disciplined investors should draw it: "You need a human intervention...to analyze that...and make decisions on it."

On the investing side, David believes you can't ignore AI as a market trend: "It's not going away...so you have to be there." But he also warns against assuming today's winners will stay the winners. "We're in the...third or fourth inning of a lot of this," he says—meaning the story is still developing. And historically, market leadership changes: "You look at the top 10 companies in the S&P from decade to decade—they're not the same."

His most practical caution may be the simplest: "How much is too much?" Whether it's valuations, hype circles, or even physical buildout like data centers—disciplined investing means knowing when the narrative has outrun reality.

Why The CIO Role Matters—Especially for Private Wealth and Multi-Generational Families

If you want to understand why a Chief Investment Officer matters, listen to the questions David hears from people of wealth.

"They'll ask you...'who's making the investment decisions? Who's on that...investment committee?"' They're not looking to micromanage. "They're not doing it, and they don't want to do it," David explains. They want to understand the governance behind the portfolio—because they know decision-making structure matters when the stakes are high.

This becomes even more important in Private Wealth relationships, where the goals don't end with one investor's lifetime.

"With larger wealth and families," David says, "you might have the added focus of managing some monies for second and third generations—even fourth generation." And he captures the mindset shift with a line that's both funny and revealing: some people joke, "I want to die and have the check bounced at the funeral home." But wealthy families don't think that way. "They want to be sure...money's left behind," because they're planning in decades, not quarters.

That "long-term, future-focused investment goals and thinking" is exactly why, as David says, "my role and the role of the investment committee is so critical."

A CIO isn't a ceremonial title. It's a governance signal. It means clarity. Consistency. Accountability. Or as David puts it, when firms aren't aligned, "it's confusing...it's not a clear message." The CIO role helps ensure the opposite: one playbook, clear responsibility, disciplined decision-making—delivered to clients who expect their wealth to be managed with the same seriousness they used to build it.

You can also read David's latest market commentary on his blog here: https://horanwealth.com/insights/markets-minute-tariff-cycle. For questions or a direct connection, email David at DavidT@horanwealth.com. To reach HORAN Wealth directly, email privatewealth@horanwealth.com.

About David Templeton, CFA®, Chief Investment Officer & Principal

David Templeton, CFA®, is Chief Investment Officer and Principal at HORAN Wealth, with more than 30 years of financial services experience spanning banking, credit analysis, and the management of institutional, nonprofit, and family investment portfolios. Over the past 15 years at HORAN Wealth, he has been a steady leader in disciplined investing and thoughtful portfolio construction designed to protect and enhance client wealth. As CIO, David leads the team responsible for investment strategy, research, and portfolio management, and he regularly shares practical market insight through his ongoing commentary. He earned his MBA from Xavier University and his BS in Business from Indiana University, and he is a member of CFA Institute® and the CFA Society® of Cincinnati.

About HORAN Wealth

HORAN Wealth is a leading wealth management firm headquartered in Cincinnati, Ohio, with a growing national footprint. As one of the largest independently owned advisory firms in Cincinnati, HORAN Wealth oversees $3.65 billion in assets under advisory and has served clients for over 75 years. The Private Wealth Practice delivers customized guidance in investment, retirement, insurance, estate, tax, and business planning—helping clients build productive and abundant lives across generations. HORAN Wealth has offices in Ohio, Kentucky, and Pennsylvania.

 

 

Securities offered through M Holdings Securities, Inc., an unaffiliated registered broker-dealer, member FINRA | SIPC. Investment advisory services offered by HORAN Wealth, LLC, registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Not FDIC Insured | No Bank Guarantee | May Lose Value

The information herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but we cannot assure its accuracy or completeness. Neither the information nor any opinion expressed constitutes a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. Any reference to past performance is not to be implied or construed as a guarantee of future results. Market conditions can vary widely over time, and there is always the potential of losing money when investing in securities. HORAN Wealth and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide and should not be relied on for tax, legal, or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal, and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.

Stay Informed. Stay Ahead.

Expand your financial knowledge with the latest insights on investing, private wealth, retirement, insurance, and business.

Why Most Estate Plans Fail—and How Legacy Planning Keeps Families Together

The Overlooked Shift in Wealthy FamiliesMore than 80% of wealthy families today are first…

Read More →

The Fed's Big Decision

After nine months of stale policy and murky economic reports, the Federal Reserve has resumed its rate cutting cycle.

Read More →

Summer 2025 Investor Letter

The long-forecasted recession predicted in recent years has not materialized and the resiliency of…

Read More →

The People Behind Your Plan

A team of specialized experts who guide you each step of the way.

“I love helping families navigate complexity, solve challenges together, and build a shared vision for the future.”

Andrea D. Costa, Esq.

Vice President, Wealth Strategy & Financial Planning

MEET ANDREA

“I absolutely love the trust we earn through the expertise and support of our team, guiding leaders to make well-informed strategic decisions.”

Michael D. Napier

Managing Partner, Wealth Advisor, Registered Principal

MEET MICHAEL

“Helping my clients navigate the complex financial world we live in and protecting their lifestyles is very personally rewarding.”

Mark A. Bennett

Principal & Portfolio Manager

MEET MARK

“Seeing the 'a-ha' moment in clients’ eyes as the years of planning have turned into the realization that they can live and prosper with spouses, family, and friends in the retirement they had hoped for and planned is beyond words.”

David Lohre, AIF®

Vice President, Wealth Advisor, Registered Representative

MEET DAVID

“I love creating tailored financial plans for clients, as it supports their goals and provides clarity for their future. It’s fulfilling to see clients gain confidence through a well-structured financial roadmap.”

Keith E. Prince, CFP®

Director of Financial Planning

MEET KEITH

“I find it incredibly rewarding to take the complexity of retirement plans off our clients’ shoulders so they can focus on growing their business, while helping their employee build a more secure future.”

Kelsey Contadino, CPFA™

Retirement Plan Advisor, Client Relationship Management

MEET KELSEY

Start Building Your Abundant Life Now